Green Awards Judging Criteria

A series of criterion are used by the Green Awards judges to determine the overall winners for each category. To help you with your application each criterion is listed below and some guidance as to what the judges are looking for has been included.

The judges will be sent the project descriptions (no more than 4 sides A4 please, using size 12 font. Any photographs must be contained within these 4 sides) from each application prior to the judges meeting. No additional supportive materials are necessary.

Demonstrate good environmental and sustainability practice

This criterion looks at the project as a whole and evaluates how 'green' it is.  Judges will be looking for evidence that the concepts of sustainable development are embodied within the project.  The most common ways to show good environmental and sustainability practice are improving energy efficiency, reducing waste, reducing water use, reducing pollution, improving the environment or improving employees' well-being.  Others could be reducing the amount of car journeys, using local food and local suppliers, addressing impact on climate change or finding new ways to use waste.

Have been implemented within the last twelve months

As the Green Awards are an annual event the projects need to be new or be on going projects with new elements or ideas.  Marking will be related to how much of the project has been implemented in the past year.  Projects may build on ideas from previous years or take several years to implement.  In these cases it should be made clear what the new aspect is and what work has been done in the previous twelve months.

Provide a good example for others to follow

The Green Awards not only reward good environmental and sustainability practice but promote good practice too.  Projects that can be replicated by other organisations or simple initiatives that others could learn from will score additional points.

Offer opportunity for staff, customer, community or pupil involvement

Participation and empowerment are important issues when thinking about sustainable development.  Therefore any project that encourages participation will gain more points.  The greater the participation the better. For instance involving staff, customers, community or pupils in the planning and decision making process of a scheme will score higher than a scheme where people are simply expected to follow directives.  High marks will also be available for projects which require a high quality involvement, commitment to the project and provide a learning experience.  People will be more inclined to make a scheme work if they have some ownership!

Incorporate savings or cost benefit

We are keen to promote initiatives that demonstrate how improvements to our environment and our society are coupled with economic benefits.  Those projects that reduce costs or improve profits by its actions to help the environment and people are likely to be truly sustainable.  A project may have direct economic benefits such as reduced energy bills or find less direct improvements such as less days lost to illness by encouraging cycling and walking.  Schemes will be marked on the balance of economic benefits within the scheme rather than on the overall monetary value of any benefits.

Are clear and comprehensive

All applications should be clear and comprehensive.  A description of the project should be included.  This can be on the application form or on separate sheets and should be no more than three sides of A4.  This will be sent to the judges prior to their meeting.  We welcome additional materials and supporting documents.  These will be viewed by the judges prior to allocating the final scores.  High marks will be given to clear, well presented applications rather than verbose, bulky documentation.

Are more than is required by duty, regulation or planning condition

Many aspects of environmental protection and social responsibility are covered by law, regulation and other duties.  Projects must show that they are doing more than just complying with what they are bound to do.  Higher marks will be achieved by exceeding any regulations that are in place

Has been received on time

To be fair we will have to deduct marks if applications are received after the closing date unless special dispensation has been given.

Total Score

Each judge will mark each application according to the above criterion.  The marks are added together for a grand total.  For each application the totals from all the judges will be added together and then divided by the number of judges.  The scores at this stage are indicative of the best projects but are used only as an important guide in the final decision of who are the winners.  The judges decision is final.

Good Luck!

Contact
Tel: 01785 619408
Fax: 01785 619119
Email: sd@staffordbc.gov.uk
How do you rate this page?